What is Dead Faith? – James 2:17

Suggest to people that salvation is by faith alone and you’re likely to hear disagreements. Many would say, “Faith is not enough. It must be accompanied by works or it’s not real. So, the person of dead faith remains an unbeliever.” James 2 is a chapter filled with controversy. Today we’ll wade into these volatile waters and look for answers and fresh insights. One thing is for sure: God wants our faith to be alive!

Discussion Questions

Why does it seem that people have a difficult time accepting that salvation is free apart from works? Why is it impossible to have the assurance of your salvation if that assurance is based on your works?

Read James 2:17. Since James wrote this epistle to Christians, what might James mean by a faith that is “dead?”

James builds his epistle around the concept of the “saving of the soul” (best translated the “preserving of life”). Read James 1:21 and 5:19-20. James is likely drawing from wisdom literature in suggesting we can preserve the physical life through obedience (compare Proverbs 10:27, 11:19, 12:28, 13:14 and 19:16).

Read James 2:14. The verse says that “faith can’t save.” How do you reconcile what appears to be a contradiction with the rest of Scripture that clearly says faith is enough for salvation (justification)? (See Ephesians 2:8-9 and Titus 3:4-6).

James 2 ends with what might be considered an unexpected conclusion about faith and works in verse 26. Works help our faith come alive. Can you think of examples where your good works helped bring life to your faith?

Perfect Judgment – Matthew 7:1-12

Maybe you’ve heard that the Bible tells us not to judge others. Perhaps you’ve even used those words to defend a mistake or misstep on your part. And yes, while there is a verse in Matthew 7 that begins like that, when context is understood, we find there is much more...

Hope and Change – Exodus 32:9-14

Can we trust God? The easy answer is, of course, but this answer is sometimes easier to say than it is to believe. When things go wrong, is God still there? When we go wrong, can we still trust God? Or will He change His mind and reject us in anger? Our experiences...

Receiving Grace In Vain – 2 Corinthians 6:1

Quite often we find ourselves racing through life, taking advantage of every opportunity, moment, and experience that comes our way. In this fast-paced reality it is incredibly easy for us to get consumed in the rush of activity, but eventually realize our priorities...

Called According to His Purpose – Rom. 8:28

Since before recorded history began, human beings have been telling stories as a way of structuring our reality. Even today, the individual stories we tell about ourselves often determine how we view the world and the type of people we become. In the book of Romans,...